The Great Chicago Fire — Passage

Premium Resource
Grades
4
5
Standards
RI.4.6
RI.5.6
PRINT+DIGITAL RESOURCE
This learning resource is available in interactive and printable formats. The interactive worksshet can be played online and assigned to students. The Printable PDF version can be downloaded and printed for completion by hand.
ABOUT THIS READER
This passage presents two accounts of the Great Chicago Fire of 1871: a firsthand diary entry and a secondhand newspaper article. Students can compare and contrast the personal, emotional narrative of Sarah Johnson with the factual, overview-style report from the Chicago Tribune. The firsthand account vividly describes the immediate danger and panic, while the secondhand account provides broader context, including the fire's cause, extent, and historical significance. This comparison helps students understand different perspectives on historical events and improves their ability to analyze various types of informational texts, aligning with CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RI.4.6 standards.
Publisher: Workybooks
|
Written by:Neha Goel Tripathi
|
Illustrated by:

Firsthand Account: Sarah Johnson's Diary Entry

October 8, 1871: I woke up to the smell of smoke and the sound of people shouting. Looking out my window, I saw flames engulfing Mrs. O'Leary's barn across the street. The fire spread quickly, and soon our entire neighborhood was ablaze. We grabbed what we could and ran towards the lake, dodging falling debris and choking on thick smoke. The heat was unbearable, and I've never been so scared in my life.

 

Secondhand Account: Chicago Tribune Article, October 10, 1871

The Great Chicago Fire began on the evening of October 8, 1871, in a barn on DeKoven Street. Strong winds helped the fire spread rapidly through the city's mostly wooden buildings. Over 17,000 structures were destroyed, leaving 100,000 residents homeless. The fire raged for two days before rain helped extinguish the flames. While the cause remains uncertain, the incident has become a significant part of Chicago's history.

How do the two accounts differ in their focus?

The firsthand account focuses on personal experiences, while the secondhand account provides an overview of the event.The firsthand account discusses the cause of the fire, while the secondhand account focuses on its aftermath.The firsthand account describes the city's response, while the secondhand account focuses on individual stories.The firsthand account provides statistics, while the secondhand account describes emotions.

Which information is unique to the secondhand account?

The date the fire startedThe number of structures destroyedThe smell of smokeThe sound of people shouting

What aspect of the fire is emphasized in the firsthand account?

The historical significance of the eventThe emotional impact and immediate dangerThe city's reconstruction effortsThe economic consequences of the fire

How does the secondhand account provide a different perspective on the fire?

It includes specific details about the author's escapeIt focuses on the fire's long-term effects on Chicago's economyIt provides a broader context, including the fire's duration and extent of damageIt describes the firefighters' efforts to control the blaze

Common core standards covered

RI.4.6
Compare and contrast a firsthand and secondhand account of the same event or topic; describe the differences in focus and the information provided.
RI.5.6
Analyze multiple accounts of the same event or topic, noting important similarities and differences in the point of view they represent.

Related Content

interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.4.6 - At The Amusement Park! - thumbnail
At The Amusement Park!
RI.4.6
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.4.6 - Point of View - thumbnail
Point of View
RI.4.6
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.4.6 - Living in the City - thumbnail
Living in the City
RI.4.6
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.5.6,RI.5.5,RI.5.8,RI.5.9 - Analyzing Perspective -Christopher Columbus - thumbnail
Analyzing Perspective -Christopher Columbus
This worksheet has students read contradictory accounts of Christopher Columbus's 1492 voyage. It th...
RI.5.6RI.5.5RI.5.8RI.5.9
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.5.6,RI.5.5,RI.5.8,RI.5.9 - Comparing Accounts of Landing on Moon - thumbnail
Comparing Accounts of Landing on Moon
This worksheet has students read two accounts of the 1969 moon landing that provide different perspe...
RI.5.6RI.5.5RI.5.8RI.5.9
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.5.6,RI.5.5,RI.5.8,RI.5.9 - Comparing News Reports- Political Protest - thumbnail
Comparing News Reports- Political Protest
This worksheet has students analyze contradictory news reports about a political protest. It uses mu...
RI.5.6RI.5.5RI.5.8RI.5.9
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.5.6,RI.5.5,RI.5.8,RI.5.9 - Penguins Supporting Evidence - thumbnail
Penguins Supporting Evidence
This informational text on penguins is a great way to practice finding the main point and reasons to...
RI.5.6RI.5.5RI.5.8RI.5.9
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.3.1,RI.4.4,RI.4.6 - The Thorny Devil - thumbnail
The Thorny Devil
The Thorny Devil is a fascinating desert lizard covered in sharp spines that protect it from predato...
RI.3.1RI.4.4RI.4.6
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.4.6,RI.5.6 - The Eruption of Mount Vesuvius - thumbnail
The Eruption of Mount Vesuvius
This passage contrasts Pliny the Younger's eyewitness account of the Mount Vesuvius eruption with a ...
RI.4.6RI.5.6
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.4.6,RI.5.6 - The First Moon Landing - thumbnail
The First Moon Landing
This passage juxtaposes Buzz Aldrin's firsthand recollection of the moon landing with a secondhand a...
RI.4.6RI.5.6
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.4.6,RI.5.6 - The Discovery of Penicillin - thumbnail
The Discovery of Penicillin
This passage compares Alexander Fleming's firsthand laboratory notes on the discovery of penicillin ...
RI.4.6RI.5.6
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.4.6,RI.5.6 - The Wright Brothers' First Flight - thumbnail
The Wright Brothers' First Flight
This passage presents two perspectives on the Wright Brothers' first flight: Orville Wright's firsth...
RI.4.6RI.5.6
Copyright © 2025 Workybooks. Made with ♥ in California.