The First Moon Landing — Passage

Grades
4
5
Standards
RI.4.6
RI.5.6
PRINT+DIGITAL RESOURCE
This learning resource is available in interactive and printable formats. The interactive worksshet can be played online and assigned to students. The Printable PDF version can be downloaded and printed for completion by hand.
ABOUT THIS READER
This passage juxtaposes Buzz Aldrin's firsthand recollection of the moon landing with a secondhand account from a New York Times article. The firsthand account offers a personal, sensory-rich description of the lunar surface and the emotional impact of the experience. In contrast, the newspaper article provides a factual overview, including specific times, the global audience, and the mission's historical significance. By comparing these accounts, students can identify differences in focus, detail, and perspective, developing critical reading skills and meeting CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RI.4.6 requirements for analyzing multiple accounts of the same event.
Publisher: Workybooks
|
Written by:Neha Goel Tripathi
|
Illustrated by:

Firsthand Account: Buzz Aldrin's Recollection

As we approached the lunar surface, I could hardly believe what I was seeing. The Moon's landscape was like nothing I'd ever encountered – stark, gray, and pockmarked with craters. When Neil and I stepped onto the surface, the feeling was indescribable. The silence was absolute, broken only by our communications with Mission Control. Looking back at Earth from the Moon's surface was a profound experience that changed my perspective forever.

 

Secondhand Account: New York Times Article, July 21, 1969

On July 20, 1969, American astronauts Neil Armstrong and Edwin "Buzz" Aldrin became the first humans to land on the Moon. Their spacecraft, Eagle, touched down on the lunar surface at 4:17 p.m. EDT. Armstrong's first step onto the Moon's surface was broadcast live to millions of viewers around the world. The astronauts spent about two and a half hours outside the spacecraft, collecting samples and taking photographs. This historic achievement marked a major milestone in space exploration and human history.

What is a key difference in the information provided by the two accounts?

The firsthand account describes personal sensations, while the secondhand account focuses on factual details and the event's significance.The firsthand account provides the exact time of the landing, while the secondhand account describes the Moon's appearance.The firsthand account mentions the live broadcast, while the secondhand account describes the astronauts' tasks on the Moon.The firsthand account discusses the spacecraft's name, while the secondhand account focuses on the astronauts' emotions.

Which detail is only mentioned in the secondhand account?

The silence on the MoonThe collection of lunar samplesThe view of Earth from the MoonThe color of the lunar surface

How does the focus of the firsthand account differ from the secondhand account?

It emphasizes the technical aspects of the missionIt concentrates on the public's reaction to the eventIt highlights the personal, emotional experience of being on the MoonIt provides a detailed timeline of the entire mission

What additional context does the secondhand account provide?

The personal backgrounds of the astronautsThe global impact and historical significance of the eventThe scientific discoveries made during the missionThe challenges faced during the spacecraft's return to Earth

Common core standards covered

RI.4.6
Compare and contrast a firsthand and secondhand account of the same event or topic; describe the differences in focus and the information provided.
RI.5.6
Analyze multiple accounts of the same event or topic, noting important similarities and differences in the point of view they represent.

Related Content

interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.4.6 - At The Amusement Park! - thumbnail
At The Amusement Park!
RI.4.6
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.4.6 - Point of View - thumbnail
Point of View
RI.4.6
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.4.6 - Living in the City - thumbnail
Living in the City
RI.4.6
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.5.6,RI.5.5,RI.5.8,RI.5.9 - Analyzing Perspective -Christopher Columbus - thumbnail
Analyzing Perspective -Christopher Columbus
This worksheet has students read contradictory accounts of Christopher Columbus's 1492 voyage. It th...
RI.5.6RI.5.5RI.5.8RI.5.9
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.5.6,RI.5.5,RI.5.8,RI.5.9 - Comparing Accounts of Landing on Moon - thumbnail
Comparing Accounts of Landing on Moon
This worksheet has students read two accounts of the 1969 moon landing that provide different perspe...
RI.5.6RI.5.5RI.5.8RI.5.9
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.5.6,RI.5.5,RI.5.8,RI.5.9 - Comparing News Reports- Political Protest - thumbnail
Comparing News Reports- Political Protest
This worksheet has students analyze contradictory news reports about a political protest. It uses mu...
RI.5.6RI.5.5RI.5.8RI.5.9
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.5.6,RI.5.5,RI.5.8,RI.5.9 - Penguins Supporting Evidence - thumbnail
Penguins Supporting Evidence
This informational text on penguins is a great way to practice finding the main point and reasons to...
RI.5.6RI.5.5RI.5.8RI.5.9
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.3.1,RI.4.4,RI.4.6 - The Thorny Devil - thumbnail
The Thorny Devil
The Thorny Devil is a fascinating desert lizard covered in sharp spines that protect it from predato...
RI.3.1RI.4.4RI.4.6
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.4.6,RI.5.6 - The Great Chicago Fire - thumbnail
The Great Chicago Fire
This passage presents two accounts of the Great Chicago Fire of 1871: a firsthand diary entry and a ...
RI.4.6RI.5.6
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.4.6,RI.5.6 - The Eruption of Mount Vesuvius - thumbnail
The Eruption of Mount Vesuvius
This passage contrasts Pliny the Younger's eyewitness account of the Mount Vesuvius eruption with a ...
RI.4.6RI.5.6
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.4.6,RI.5.6 - The Discovery of Penicillin - thumbnail
The Discovery of Penicillin
This passage compares Alexander Fleming's firsthand laboratory notes on the discovery of penicillin ...
RI.4.6RI.5.6
interactive | printable worksheet on CCSS RI.4.6,RI.5.6 - The Wright Brothers' First Flight - thumbnail
The Wright Brothers' First Flight
This passage presents two perspectives on the Wright Brothers' first flight: Orville Wright's firsth...
RI.4.6RI.5.6
Copyright © 2025 Workybooks. Made with ♥ in California.