Lincoln-Douglas Debates 1858: Slavery in Territories — Reading Comprehension

In the summer and fall of 1858, Abraham Lincoln and Stephen A. Douglas faced each other in a series of seven public debates while running for the U.S. Senate from Illinois. The main issue at stake was whether slavery should be allowed to expand into new western territories. Their arguments revealed deep divisions in the United States and shaped the nation's future.

At this time, the U.S. was rapidly growing westward. New territories were being settled, and Americans disagreed sharply over whether slavery should be legal in those areas. Some people, like Stephen Douglas, believed in popular sovereignty. This meant that people living in each territory should vote to decide if slavery would be allowed. Douglas argued, "If the people of any territory want slavery, they have a right to it." He defended this idea as democratic and fair, but others saw problems with it.

Abraham Lincoln took a different position. Lincoln believed that slavery was morally wrong and should not be allowed to expand, although he did not call for its immediate end where it already existed. Lincoln feared that the spread of slavery would make it impossible for the nation to live up to its founding ideals of liberty and equality. In one debate, he stated, "A house divided against itself cannot stand." This famous quote showed his belief that the country could not last permanently half-slave and half-free.

The debates did not just focus on the law. The two men also discussed the Constitution, the role of Congress, and the rights of both black and white Americans. Douglas accused Lincoln of wanting equality for African Americans, which was unpopular with many white voters at the time. Lincoln responded that he simply opposed the expansion of slavery, not full social or political equality. This revealed a contradiction: Lincoln wanted to limit slavery but was cautious about openly advocating for full rights for all people.

Both sides used historical reasoning and evidence to support their views. Douglas cited the Kansas-Nebraska Act as proof that popular sovereignty worked. Lincoln referred to the Declaration of Independence to argue that freedom was a founding American principle. Their debates forced citizens to think about what kind of nation the United States should become.

The outcome of the debates was complex. Douglas won the Senate seat, but Lincoln's powerful arguments made him famous across the country. The debates increased tensions between North and South, as each region had different economic interests and moral beliefs about slavery. These tensions would soon erupt into the Civil War.

Ultimately, the Lincoln-Douglas Debates helped Americans see that the issue of slavery in the territories was not simply a local matter. It was a national crisis that tested democracy, the Constitution, and the meaning of freedom. The debates did not resolve the conflict, but they set the stage for the intense struggles that followed.

Interesting Fact: After losing the Senate race, Abraham Lincoln used the fame he gained from the debates to successfully run for President in 1860.

Who won the 1858 Senate race?

How many debates did Lincoln and Douglas have?

What main issue did the debates address?

What did Douglas believe in?

What did Lincoln fear about slavery's expansion?

Why did the debates increase tensions?

Lincoln supported slavery's expansion. True or false?

What does 'popular sovereignty' mean?