Introducing KNOVA — A free reading app with curriculum-aligned passages on History & Science for Grades 3-8Learn More →

Native American Treaties — Reading Comprehension

No ratings yet

Premium Resource

Grades

Standards

D2.HIS.2.3-5
D2.HIS.3.3-5
RI.4.3
RI.4.4
W.4.2

Rate this resource

Send Feedback / Report an Issue

About This Reader

This passage examines early Native American treaties, agreements that were meant to establish peace and boundaries between tribal nations and colonial or U.S. governments. Students will analyze the causes and effects of treaty violations, the role of sovereignty, and the consequences for both Native peoples and the expansion of the United States. The content addresses historical complexity, encourages evidence-based reasoning, and is aligned with standards HSS 5.4.4, 8.8; CCSS.RI.6-8.1, and RI.6-8.2. The passage is presented at an accessible reading level with a differentiated version for developing readers, as well as a full Spanish translation. Activities include multiple-choice questions, explanatory writing prompts, and graphic organizers. Read aloud audio is available. This resource is ideal for building historical understanding and literacy skills.

CONTENT PREVIEW

BROKEN TREATIES — 1830 Indian Removal Act forced Native peoples like the Cherokee, Creek, and Seminole to leave their ancestral lands and move west of the Mississippi River.

The first treaties between Native American nations and colonial governments were intended to establish peace and clear boundaries. These treaties were legal agreements, often negotiated after conflict or to avoid future disputes. For Native communities, signing a treaty was a way to protect their land, rights, and sovereignty—the power to govern themselves. Colonial and later U.S. officials, however, often saw treaties as tools for acquiring more land and expanding settlements.

From the 1600s through the 1800s, hundreds of treaties were made. Each one was supposed to be a promise. Some treaties set boundaries for Native lands, others promised goods or protection. The process of ratification—official approval by the U.S. government—was supposed to make these agreements binding. Despite this, the United States often failed to uphold its side of the deal.

One major problem was that as more settlers arrived, there was increasing pressure to open Native lands for farming and towns. Whenever valuable resources like gold or fertile soil were found, settlers and officials demanded further land cessions. This led to repeated violation of earlier treaties. Native nations protested these violations, sometimes taking their cases to American courts or resisting through diplomacy. However, their efforts rarely stopped the loss of land or forced relocation.

The consequences of broken treaties were severe. Native American families were pushed from their homes, often onto much smaller reservations. The promises of supplies and protection were frequently ignored. The loss of land and autonomy weakened tribal governments and their ability to protect their cultures. Meanwhile, the United States grew larger and wealthier through these unfair exchanges.

Despite the pattern of broken agreements, Native leaders continued to negotiate and fight for their rights. Some treaties, like the Treaty of Fort Laramie in 1851, briefly secured peace and defined tribal territories. But even these were soon ignored when new waves of settlers arrived. The cycle of promise and betrayal left a lasting legacy of mistrust and injustice.

Today, many Native nations continue to seek justice for old treaty violations. Some have won legal cases or settlements that recognize the validity of their original agreements. Understanding this history helps us see why treaties are more than just old documents—they represent promises, struggles, and the ongoing fight for Native rights.

Interesting Fact: The United States made nearly 400 treaties with Native American nations—and broke almost every single one.

What was the main purpose of early treaties?

To create peace and set boundariesTo start warsTo build cities togetherTo share gold and silver

What is sovereignty?

Power to govern oneselfA type of treatyA land boundaryA violation

What usually happened when settlers wanted more land?

Treaties were often brokenNative lands expandedSettlers left the landGold was given to Native nations

Why did Native nations sign treaties?

To protect land and rightsTo become U.S. citizensTo build fortsTo trade gold

What was an effect of broken treaties?

Loss of Native land and autonomyMore Native sovereigntyEqual land sharingGrowth of tribal governments

What did the Treaty of Fort Laramie try to do?