Introducing KNOVA — A free reading app with curriculum-aligned passages on History & Science for Grades 3-8Learn More →

Leaders Call for a New Constitution — Reading Comprehension

No ratings yet

Premium Resource

Grades

Rate this resource

Send Feedback / Report an Issue

About This Reader

This reading passage explores the pivotal moment in U.S. history when American leaders recognized the weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation and called for a convention to create a new Constitution. Covering the causes, debates, and consequences of the Constitutional Convention of 1787, the passage examines conflicts, multiple perspectives, and the reasons why a new government structure was necessary. Aligned with D2.His.2.6-8, D2.His.3.6-8, and RI.6.3, RI.6.4, it encourages students to analyze historical evidence and understand the impact of compromise and debate in shaping the United States. The resource includes a reading passage, differentiated and Spanish versions, a glossary, reading comprehension quiz, writing activities, and graphic organizers. Perfect for students and teachers seeking a comprehensive U.S. history resource with read-aloud audio and Spanish translation.

CONTENT PREVIEW

"Convention at Philadelphia, 1787" / Library of Congress.

The Constitutional Convention of 1787 was a crucial meeting that shaped the future of the United States. Delegates from twelve states gathered in Philadelphia to address the serious problems facing the country under the Articles of Confederation. The Articles, which served as America's first government, had created a national government that was too weak to solve important issues, such as collecting taxes or regulating trade.

The delegates—fifty-five men representing their states—met in secrecy at Independence Hall. Their goal was to create a stronger national government. Among them were notable leaders like George Washington, who presided over the convention, and James Madison, who became known as the "Father of the Constitution" for his detailed notes and ideas. Each delegate brought different opinions and priorities, making decision-making especially challenging.

One of the main problems they faced was finding the right balance between power for the states and power for the national government. Many small states feared losing their influence if population determined representation in Congress. Larger states wanted more say because they had more people. This conflict led to the Great Compromise, which created a two-house legislature: the Senate, where each state had equal representation, and the House of Representatives, where representation was based on population.

Another major disagreement involved slavery. Southern states wanted enslaved people counted in their populations to increase their representation, while northern states disagreed. The Three-Fifths Compromise settled this issue by counting three out of every five enslaved people for both representation and taxation. This compromise demonstrated how the delegates used negotiation to reach agreements, even on difficult subjects.

Beyond these debates, the convention produced several lasting principles. The new Constitution established a system of checks and balances so that no single branch—executive, legislative, or judicial—could become too powerful. It also included a process for amendment, allowing the Constitution to be changed as needed. The goal was to create a strong but flexible government that would endure over time.

Once the Constitution was written, it still had to be approved by the states—a process called ratification. This was not easy, as many Americans feared giving too much power to a central government. Supporters, called Federalists, wrote essays explaining why the new Constitution was necessary. Opponents, known as Anti-Federalists, worried about the lack of individual rights. To gain support, the Bill of Rights—ten amendments guaranteeing basic freedoms—was promised and added soon after ratification.

In conclusion, the Constitutional Convention of 1787 solved problems that threatened the survival of the United States through debate, compromise, and careful planning. The Constitution they created formed the basis for American government and continues to guide the nation today.

Interesting Fact: George Washington was so respected that his presence at the Convention helped persuade others to attend and support the final Constitution.

Where did the Convention take place?

PhiladelphiaNew YorkBostonRichmond

Who presided over the Convention?

George WashingtonBenjamin FranklinJames MadisonThomas Jefferson

What was the main goal of the Convention?

Strengthen national governmentDeclare independenceStart a warElect a president

Why did small states worry about representation?

Larger states might control CongressTaxes were too highThey wanted to end slaveryThey disliked compromise

What did the Three-Fifths Compromise decide?

Counted enslaved people for representationEnded slaveryCreated the Supreme CourtGave states equal votes

How did the Bill of Rights help ratification?

Promised basic freedomsBanned all taxesCreated the SenateSupported Anti-Federalists