Skip to main content
Reading PassagePremium

Why Isn't Pluto a Planet

Interactive passage with audio narration, comprehension questions, and printable PDF.

No ratings yet
Grades 5–8ScienceElaEnglish · SpanishInteractive · Printable
Aligned toMS-ESS1-3
Just this resource
$1.50
One-time purchase
Best value
Unlock everything
$49.99$29.99/yr
40% off until Aug 1 — 10,000+ resources
Renews at $49.99/year.
Unlock above to use these actions

What's included

Reading passage
Audio narration
Comprehension quiz
Writing activity
Glossary & flashcards
Differentiated version
Spanish translation

Why Isn't Pluto a Planet preview and details

About this printable Why Isn't Pluto a Planet science reading passage, NGSS-aligned (Grades 5-8)

This engaging 400-500 word science reading passage for grades 6-8 explores why Pluto is no longer classified as a planet. Aligned with NGSS standards MS-ESS1-3 and MS-ESS1.B, the passage examines the 2006 decision by the International Astronomical Union to formalize the planet definition. Students learn about the three criteria objects must meet to be classified as planets: orbiting the Sun, having enough mass to be spherical, and clearing their orbital region. The passage explains how Pluto meets two criteria but shares its orbital space with many Kuiper Belt objects, leading to its reclassification as a dwarf planet. Through cause-and-effect reasoning, students discover how scientific definitions evolve as knowledge expands. The content includes audio integration, vocabulary development with 8-10 key science terms, Spanish translations, differentiated versions for struggling readers, comprehension questions, writing activities, and graphic organizers. This comprehensive resource helps students understand that science is a dynamic process where classifications change based on new evidence and improved understanding of our solar system.
Written by Workybooks TeamPublished by Workybooks
Preview

Sample passage and quiz from Why Isn't Pluto a Planet

Reading passage and comprehension quiz preview

Why Isn't Pluto a Planet

Pluto in True Color
Four images from NASA's New Horizons' Long Range Reconnaissance Imager (LORRI) were combined with color data from the Ralph instrument to create this global view of Pluto "Pluto in True Color" / NASA 

Pluto is not classified as a planet because it does not meet all three criteria established by the International Astronomical Union in 2006. Scientists decided that a celestial body must fulfill specific requirements to be called a planet. This decision changed how we understand objects in our solar system.

The IAU established three criteria for planet classification. First, an object must orbit the Sun. Second, it must have enough mass for gravity to pull it into a spherical shape. Third, it must have cleared its orbital region of other debris. Pluto meets the first two criteria successfully. It orbits the Sun in an elliptical path. Its gravity has pulled it into a round shape. However, Pluto fails the third criterion because it shares its orbital space with thousands of other objects.

Evidence shows that Pluto resides in the Kuiper Belt, a region beyond Neptune filled with icy bodies. Scientists observe that Pluto's orbit overlaps with many similar-sized objects in this zone. The planet Neptune, in comparison, has cleared nearly all debris from its orbital path. Pluto's mass is too small to gravitationally dominate its neighborhood. This discovery led astronomers to create a new category called dwarf planets. Dwarf planets orbit the Sun and have spherical shapes but have not cleared their orbits.

The reclassification of Pluto demonstrates how scientific definitions evolve as knowledge increases. Before 2006, astronomers lacked a formal definition of what makes a planet. New telescope technology revealed hundreds of Kuiper Belt objects similar to Pluto. Scientists needed clearer categories to organize these discoveries. The IAU's decision was not about Pluto changing but about our understanding improving. This process shows that science adapts when new evidence emerges.

Understanding why Pluto is a dwarf planet matters because it teaches us how science works. Classifications help scientists communicate clearly about celestial objects. As technology improves, we can discover more about distant regions of our solar system. The debate about Pluto reminds us that scientific knowledge grows over time. New observations can lead to better ways of organizing information about our universe.

Interesting Fact: Pluto has five known moons, and its largest moon Charon is so big that Pluto and Charon orbit a point in space between them rather than Charon simply orbiting Pluto.

Comprehension quiz (10 questions)

1. When did the International Astronomical Union formally define what a planet is?

2000
2006
2010
1999

2. How many criteria must a celestial body meet to be classified as a planet?

Two
Four
Three
Five

3. What does it mean for a planet to have 'cleared its orbital region'?

It has moved away from the Sun
It has removed most debris from its orbital path
It has a perfectly circular orbit
It has no moons

4. Where is Pluto located in our solar system?

Between Mars and Jupiter
In the asteroid belt
In the Kuiper Belt beyond Neptune
Closer to the Sun than Earth

5. Which criterion for planet classification does Pluto NOT meet?

Orbiting the Sun
Having a spherical shape
Clearing its orbital region
Having enough mass

6. Based on the passage, why did scientists create the category of dwarf planets?

To honor Pluto specifically
To classify objects that orbit the Sun and are spherical but haven't cleared their orbits
To remove Pluto from astronomy textbooks
To make the solar system smaller

7. What does the reclassification of Pluto demonstrate about science?

Scientific definitions never change
Scientists make mistakes frequently
Scientific definitions evolve as knowledge increases
Old discoveries are always wrong

8. How does Neptune differ from Pluto in terms of its orbit?

Neptune is closer to the Sun
Neptune has cleared nearly all debris from its orbital path
Neptune does not orbit the Sun
Neptune is not spherical

9. Pluto physically changed in 2006, which is why it lost its planet status.

True
False

10. The Kuiper Belt contains thousands of icy objects similar to Pluto.

True
False
Who it's for

Perfect for the way you teach

Teachers
  • Build comprehension skills
  • Auto-graded quiz
  • Differentiated reading
Parents
  • Read together at home
  • Improve fluency
  • Quiet reading time
Homeschoolers
  • Reading curriculum support
  • Independent practice
  • Track Lexile growth
Topics

Reviews & Ratings

No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!

More reading you might love

20 more
Passage
Sunspots and Solar Flares - reading educational content
Grades 4–5

Sunspots and Solar Flares

earth and space science · RI.4.1

Free
Passage
The Hottest Planet in the Solar System - reading educational content
Grades 3–7

The Hottest Planet in the Solar System

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-3

Free
Passage
Mercury: Closest to the Sun - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

Mercury: Closest to the Sun

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-2

$1.50
Passage
Venus: Earth's Twin? - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

Venus: Earth's Twin?

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-2

$1.50
Passage
Mars: The Red Planet - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

Mars: The Red Planet

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-2

$1.50
Passage
What Is the Solar System? - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

What Is the Solar System?

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-2

$1.50
Passage
Structure of the Solar System - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

Structure of the Solar System

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-2

$1.50
Passage
Scale of the Solar System - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

Scale of the Solar System

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-3

$1.50
Passage
Exploration of the Solar System - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

Exploration of the Solar System

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-3

$1.50
Passage
Optical Telescopes - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

Optical Telescopes

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-3

$1.50
Passage
Future of Alien Search - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

Future of Alien Search

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-3

$1.50
Passage
Communicating with Aliens - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

Communicating with Aliens

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-3

$1.50
Passage
Measuring Distances in Space - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

Measuring Distances in Space

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-3

$1.50
Passage
 Astronomy - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

Astronomy

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-2

$1.50
Passage
The Solar System - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

The Solar System

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-2

$1.50
Passage
The Inner Planets - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

The Inner Planets

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-2

$1.50
Passage
The Outer Planets - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

The Outer Planets

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-2

$1.50
Passage
Light-Years and Cosmic Distances - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

Light-Years and Cosmic Distances

science · MS-ESS1-3

$1.50
Passage
Space Stations - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

Space Stations

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-3

$1.50
Passage
Types of Spacecraft - reading educational content
Grades 5–8

Types of Spacecraft

earth and space science · MS-ESS1-3

$1.50
Copyright © 2026 Workybooks. Made with ♥ in California.